Support and maintenance
Desktops give you much more oomph per £. Laptops are also more expensive to
repair when they break but if you want portability it's got to be a laptop, tablet or even smartphone. I like
having a variety of devices available; desktop for photo editing etc,
laptop or tablet for portable computing and smartphone for ultra portability.
It doesn't matter so much nowadays, since so much of
what we do is through a browser, but...
is what we run on our desktop and laptop computers and is very good
indeed. The best operating system I've ever used. Windows 7 was
pretty good too, although slower to start and with a tiny limit on disk partitions.
Here's my desktop running Win 10 across 2 HD monitors:
are nicely designed but not cheap and are a bit niche (under 10%
so most people don't know how OS X works).
running Chrome OS are interesting if your computing needs are mainly
browsing the web and dong emails and you want a proper keyboard. Chromebooks are cheap and need
very little tinkering but need an internet connection to function. Ideal for granny?
Tablets and smartphones mostly run on Google's Android
or Apple's iOS
with Microsoft trying to join the party. I really like Android 4 and 5 - very
easy to use (especially with the separate back and task switch buttons that are missing from iOS).
But I do all my real work (websites, photo and video editing etc) on real computers.
Most people will check things out online now. It's hard to avoid amazon but I always check
out a multitude of suppliers, depending on what I'm searching for.
If it's a smartphone I'd check giffgaff, amazon, carphone warehouse etc
but ended up getting my son's HTC One when he got a newer phone. My wife's Moto G was
from amazon. For tablets it could be direct from Google or Apple but we got ours
from Currys and Tesco. Our Acer mini laptop came from SVP and desktop from
Dell. I always check John Lewis and PC World too and considered Braebo for our new desktop.
Looking around really does work - our desktop plus laptop plus two tablets, all very capable,
cost around £800 the lot. Many people shell out that sort of amount for just a laptop
or a couple of tablets.
Support and maintenance
For some devices it's basically a matter of hoping it lasts well and
replacing it when it breaks, eg when you drop your tablet and the screen cracks. For my Asus tablet
I got (and have used) very reasonable 3 year all risks cover from Currys. For computers what you really need is
someone who'll fix the machine for the first
few years and give you technical support indefinitely (eg if Windows will not start
or you get a nasty virus). There's a tendency for
suppliers to duck out of support obligations now - some will offer reasonable
hardware warranties but will not be interested in helping if the
machine is unusable because of a software fault (eg Windows needs
re-installing). Quite often the only realistic option will be to do a factory
reset yourself then re-install all your programs again (and recover your data if it wasn't
on a separate partition).
Basically, ask yourself "what happens if the hardware and/or
operating system goes crunch - next month, next year and after 3+ years?"
One other thing to think about: our two Win 10 computers each has a system
drive, C: and a separate partition (D:) for data. That means
taking an image of the system drive every so often is quite quick and a
couple of times over the years I've used an image to reset a computer
to a few weeks back (installed programs and all) without
affecting the data.
On tablets and smartphones the basics come with them and you can add
all sorts of extras via app stores.
On a computer, apart from the operating system you need security plus an office suite
(word processing etc) then something for images, sound, video or whatever, according to taste.
For security you can pay for Kaspersky, Norton etc (does your existing subscription cover multiple PCs?)
or else use free security software, eg from Avast.
For word processing, spreadsheets and presentations there's always the free
Libre Office. It's a little slow at times but pretty good and can
read and save in Microsoft formats.
For images the FastStone Image Viewer
personal use) is amazingly good and does some editing too. Photoshop Elements
is wonderful for any sort of image processing. For video editing I use Sony Vegas.
For music there's a wealth of free players and organisers, eg iTunes,
Windows Media Player and VLC (my favourite).
One program I use all the time is Primo PDF. Anything you can print you can divert via Primo to a pdf
file. I use it for invoices, storing copies of important emails and all sorts of other things.
They get better and cheaper month by month and you often have to spend
more to get real speed, big screens or miniaturisation. Make sure there
are plenty of connectors, eg 3 USB ports is better than 2 and at least one should be a fast USB3 one (usually blue).
Processors, hard disks and memory are largely a matter of what you spend. I think spending more on a bigger
disk and more memory and stepping down to a less expensive processor is
most effective. But don't skimp too much. If you look up a processor via
a Passmark score of over 3000 should be OK for running Windows 10.
Make sure you've got an Ethernet network port. Wifi capability is essential, with wireless n
OK but ac much better. Bluetooth can also be useful for connecting to phones and other gadgets. HDMI is good
for connecting to a TV. Most say a touch screen on a laptop is pointless. Many laptops are now coming with
SSDs (Solid State Drives). Our Acer has one and seems very fast but there's not enough storage for
all our music and photos. Big SSDs are still relatively expensive.
Battery power is a real issue with laptops. Many last no more than 2-3 hours away from the mains
and the batteries don't seem to last many years. Some people say you'll get years more from
your laptop battery if you take it out any time you don't need to work
on battery power - I also read it's better to store Lithium Ion batteries part discharged (say 60%)
and avoid completely discharging them or leaving them mostly 100% charged - they especially hate
being full and hot.
As of July 2016 reasonable basic Windows 10 laptops start around £350 (more with decent
warranties) but you really do need to do the research to see what will suit you. And you'll only get
a 1366x768 screen at the cheaper end of the market. We've got a little £350 Windows 10 Acer with a 13.3"
HD screen and 120Gb SSD as a home + holiday laptop. Always check for processor speed, memory (2Gb really is mean!),
battery oomph, USB3 and HDMI as well as screen size, quality and resolution. And how can you tell what the keyboard is like
without trying it?
You can easily top £1000 for fancier laptops but that's not necessary
if you don't do anything too demanding. They get faster so relentlessly over time that any new machine
will be pretty good beside a really expensive one from 3 years ago.
If you want more flexibility and power and are happy for your main
computer to stay in one place a desktop definitely gives you a lot more
speed and power for the money than a laptop - but beware power
consumption. If you use a computer a lot then the extra
speed, bigger screen and better keyboard and mouse of a desktop makes a
laptop seem a very crude alternative.
One big advantage is that it's much easier and cheaper
to recover from hardware problems with a desktop, eg if the screen dies just get
another one - they keep getting bigger and cheaper. Our last
desktop had become very noisy at one stage and I fixed it in half an hour with a new
£5 case fan bought online. I've also made my desktop visually much better to
use by getting a 2nd monitor. In the image below I've got my local collection of
safari images on the right and the flickr organizer online on the left. You can also stretch
a video or audio timeline across both of them.
You can also use specialised desktops as media centres,
although I prefer a dedicated PVR - much cheaper and simpler to use too.
There are small desktops that are a
compromise between desktops and laptops. They are slim, may use laptop
components and should be fine for most tasks if you don't play the
latest games or do heavy video editing. There are also all in one computers - space
saving but if the screen goes you have to throw the rest away.
The 10" iPad led the way and tablets of all sorts are still selling well despite phones getting bigger.
The immediacy of turning on from standby and being online within a second or so is pretty compelling.
But for me a tablet just doesn't do a lot compared with a real computer. It has
nothing close to the slickness of browsing, typing, photo editing etc on a
real computer (tablets nearly all run phone operating systems). The touch
interface is intuitive to a point but far too crude for anything like
delicate photo editing. For a start it's often hard to know what all those
little symbols mean (no equivalent to hovering with the mouse, no right
click) and touching the wrong one can have unfortunate results. And typing
is a pain - the on-screen keyboard takes up far too much of the small screen
and you have to keep swapping to a different keyboard to get punctuation and
numbers. And yet the big brand tablets cost a lot and have hardly any storage -
nowhere near enough for our music and photos, let alone videos. iPads also
have virtually no ports: no USB, no microSD (to expand memory), no HDMI, no
ethernet, no OTG. And all these tablets are going to be slabs of junk when their
batteries fail, as they will all too soon.
Smaller tablets are more interesting in a way, as they are so much more portable than a
10" one. I find a 4.7" phone, 7" tablet, 13.3 laptop and
desktop with 22 and 23" HD monitors cover what I want very well. Others have just
a 6" phone plus a laptop.
Google (Nexus), Apple and Samsung have high quality tablet ranges. There are lots of
others, including the Kindle Fire, mainly geared to buying content from amazon and lacking
the crucial Google Play store. I got a no-name Chinese 8" Android 4 tablet in 2012 and
that was OK - plenty of storage via a cheap SD card but a bit slow on web browsing
and with a poor battery life. So I gave it to a friend and got an Asus MemoPad HD 7 from Currys.
It's fantastic for just £130, fast, excellent screen and a very good battery life. And unlike
its Google and Apple rivals it lets you expand the storage cheaply with an SD card. So does
my wife's Tesco Hudl, shown on the right, which we got mainly with Tesco vouchers.
On safari I'd connect our camera cards to it via a cheap OTG cable, review and delete on the very
sharp screen then copy the ones we kept onto the tablet and thence to a memory pen so
I had 3 copies of all our photos at the end of each day. The people with iPads couldn't
believe such a cheap tablet could be so much better than theirs, out in the field with
little or no wifi.
So we're very nicely set up, now, with Chrome running quickly and synching its
bookmarks across our desktop, laptop and tablets. There's a good Gmail client on the tablets
(and all our contact details arrive automatically). Dropbox Pro keeps all our data
files in sych across desktop, laptop, tablets and phones and OneNote does the same for notes. My tablet's proved excellent
for navigation in unfamiliar places (Nokia Here) and is a super photo album and video player (QuickPic and
MX Player are much better than the Android defaults). I can even get films off our PVR, convert them to mp4
and copy them onto the tablets, great for long flights. Some other
apps I've downloaded (mostly free) are The Guardian (free offline content), Avast for security, Google Earth, Nokia
Here (stores complete country maps for use offline) and the Met Office weather app. Also several games; Angry
Birds plays very well, as does Bad Pigs and Bubble Wars. I also got
Sketcher Pro, Magic Doodle Premium, Picasso and My Piano for something
different (and with grandchildren in mind).
These are small computers that can do an amazing amount. Apple
really got this market buzzing with its very popular and accomplished
iPhone. Then Samsung and others got going with Android
smartphones, which surged into the lead and are still gaining market share rapidly. The trouble
for me was that they were so expensive - £400+ for a good SIM free phone or else a
lengthy, expensive contract with a 'free' phone. Then my son gave me his old HTC
Hero (a top end phone in 2009). That was fine for a couple of years then when it
lost its touch response I bought a Huawei G300, SIM free for £130.
That only lasted a couple of years but compared with getting a contract I'm
so far ahead financially, especially as I now have an HTC One (M7) my son passed on to me
when he got a new phone. So is my wife - our son gave her his old Samsung SII and when that eventually
died she got a Motorola Moto G for £160. It's astonishingly good value and makes
me wonder why people are spending £500+ on only slightly better models, mostly through expensive
long term contracts.
I did the research a while back and found O2 spinoff giffgaff. It's perfect
for a SIM free Android phone - you can stay on Pay As You Go and mainly
use wifi for internet connections (mobile internet on PAYG is only 20p per
day if you keep usage low). Or for £7.50 for a month you get 500Gb of 4g
internet on the move, unlimited texts and 250 minutes talk time. That's more
than either of us ever actually need. At the
end of the month you can revert to PAYG (eg if abroad on holiday) or
pay for another month - very flexible.
So now I can use Google maps (with live traffic updates and bus/tube departures) on
the move or check anything I like via the web browser or apps. When there's no
decent signal I can still play Angry Birds or read a brilliant selection of articles
via the Guardian app (you can download them via wifi before leaving).
I still find a 4.7" HD smartphone screen rather limited for internet
browsing and a tablet is far better for internet and emails.